How Good Accountant chooses and orders accountants, tax advisers, bookkeepers and insolvency practitioners
The four lists on Good Accountant and the question each one answers, who is left out, what is free and what is paid, and which register to read to check what we cannot.
Updated
Choosing an accountant is hard because the word covers a bookkeeper working from a spare room, a chartered firm with forty staff and a company that exists only as a website. Good Accountant keeps four separate lists so that each one answers a single question, and a firm only appears where it does that job.
No professional body in the UK owns the word "accountant", so none of our lists can be read as a licence. What we can do is put the firms that do the work in front, show how to check the rest, and say plainly what we have not checked.
How a firm reaches a list
- It is a firm that does the work of that list, which we judge from what it says it does and how it describes its own services.
- Its public record is read: what clients say about it and how long it has been doing it.
- Its own website and public profiles are read for what it does, who it works for and where it is.
- It is placed by merit. Nothing here is for sale.
The four lists, one question each
Accountants
The list for most people and most small businesses.
- THE QUESTION
- Who can keep my accounts and deal with HMRC for me?Firms that prepare annual accounts, tax returns and the routine filings for sole traders, partnerships and limited companies.
- WHAT YOU CAN NARROW TO
- Small businesses, the self-employed, landlords, contractors in the construction scheme, doctors and dentists, charities and forensic accounting.
- WHO IS LEFT OUT
- HMRC and other public offices, banks and insurers, mortgage brokers, estate agents, software suppliers, recruitment agencies, accountancy training providers, solicitors, debt collectors and debt charities. Large national firms stay in.
Tax advisers
For a problem or a decision, rather than a yearly return.
- THE QUESTION
- Who can advise me on a tax decision or a tax problem?Firms that handle tax planning, an inheritance, the sale of a property or shares, or a letter from HMRC.
- WHAT YOU CAN NARROW TO
- Inheritance tax and estates, capital gains and property tax, and HMRC enquiries.
- WHO IS LEFT OUT
- Anyone whose only service is a routine return. A firm that does both appears on this list and on the accountants list, which is deliberate.
Bookkeepers
The month-to-month records behind the accounts.
- THE QUESTION
- Who can keep my records and invoices up to date?Firms and freelancers who run day-to-day records, VAT returns and payroll for small employers.
- WHAT YOU CAN NARROW TO
- Payroll. It has too few firms of its own in most towns to stand as a list.
- WHO IS LEFT OUT
- Software sellers and training providers, and firms that only file a yearly tax return.
Insolvency practitioners
The one list where the word is regulated.
- THE QUESTION
- Who can act when a company or a person cannot pay what is owed?Firms that say they run liquidations, company voluntary arrangements and similar procedures.
- WHAT WE DO NOT DO
- We do not licence anyone. Only a licensed insolvency practitioner can act as a liquidator or administrator, so check the person on the Insolvency Service search before you sign anything. The steps are on our check an accountant page.
- WHERE IT APPEARS
- Only in places where we can list at least five firms, which today is a handful of cities.
What is free and what is paid
Being on a list
Free for every firm that passes the selection. A firm cannot ask to be added, moved up or taken off a rival's list in exchange for anything.
A firm can claim its entry for free and correct its details, hours and services.
Pro and Top
Pro is a fuller profile for a firm already listed. It does not change where the firm sits. Top is one of the three highest places in a list, always marked as paid. Only firms that were already on the list can take either.
Where to check what we cannot
| If the firm says | The register to read |
|---|---|
| Chartered accountant, ACA or FCA | ICAEW directory, and ICAEW's misdescribers list |
| ACCA | ACCA member and firm directories |
| AAT licensed | AAT, find an accountant or bookkeeper |
| Chartered tax adviser or ATT | CIOT member search and ATT member search |
| Supervised for money laundering by HMRC | HMRC Supervised Business Register |
| Insolvency practitioner | Insolvency Service search |
| A limited company | Companies House company search |
A firm supervised by its own professional body will not show on HMRC's register. That is why the table sends you to the body first.
If a listing is wrong
Write to us from the contact page, saying which firm and what is wrong, and ideally with a link to the firm's own website or register entry. We correct the entry when we have seen the evidence, and a firm that has stopped trading or lost its membership comes off the list. Lists are reread regularly, and each page says when it was last checked.
Good Accountant editorial team